Fingers & toes

I have an issue with some inconsistency regarding to toe/finger tags

Tags we have:
extra_toes, extra_finger, missing_toe, missing_finger, extra_digits

So
1. extra_toes is in plural, the 3 other ones are not
2. extra_digits is redundant and just carried over from Danbooru, and also "extra_fingers" is aliased to this and that's why people use "extra_finger" instead to have a way-around for this.

A BUR has to be made, but not really sure exactly what to do. Do we go with plurals or singular? Should extra_digits go away completely or do we go with implications? Danbooru has fewer_digits as well, but as there are no aliases nor implications linked to it, I don't think this tag is an issue.

My opinion would be:
1) Get rid of extra_digits completely
2) Alias plurals to singulars (so instead of extra_toes we would have extra_toe).

Lyren said:

My opinion would be:
1) Get rid of extra_digits completely
2) Alias plurals to singulars (so instead of extra_toes we would have extra_toe).

Seems reasonable to me - I'm also not sure how often those tags would be/are used if quality checks/approval system filter most of them out dealing with ai gens and all.

BUR #200 has been rejected.

create alias extra_digits -> extra_finger

Both tags serve the same purpose and the latter fits the standard naming contention of being singular over plural.

The problem with aliasing it to extra_finger is that extra_digits can mean/used for both toes and fingers.

Lyren said:

The problem with aliasing it to extra_finger is that extra_digits can mean/used for both toes and fingers.

That's a great point I didn't even consider. x_x

The bulk update request #200 (forum #1441) has been rejected by @SONYA.