Image Replacement Request Thread

Posted under General

Iroshi

eyeviewer said:

Change post #147685 for https://storage.imgbly.com/imgbly/JScrCLVCfh.png

Changed a few details. Straps added. Smile brighter. Hopefully this gets the image approved already.

@eyeviewer While the effort to improve is appreciated and welcome, the proposed replacement cannot be done.
Because the resolution is lower. It should either be just as big, or bigger (like replacing samples). Also, it looks worse in the line details (aliasing), zoom to the breast pocket for example and see the lines are less nitid. Even in the newer one, the hand on the table has a problem that the old one doesn't, check the hand-shirt interaction in the forearm (before the wrist). Overall in the details it seems inferior.
The resolution mismatch and the other issues would need to be improved for the replacement to go through

ShaddAI said:

Replace post #148143 with https://files.catbox.moe/zrlsht.png
Accidentally uploaded the censored pixiv version.

Delivered

Reply
yureivoid

Iroshi said:

@yureivoid The replacement has been delivered. But for the next time, you should not ask for an approval. If a post is good, it will naturally get approved eventually, without the need to bring it to greater attention

got it, thank you!

Reply
Iroshi

Speed_Cirno said:

Replace post #151062
New Image: asset #593969

Was testing things out & didn't realize that my IMG2IMG kept enlarging the image. (was set to scale instead of size) sorry about that. 3mb is a lot more sensible then 30+

Delivered

You made a reasonable choice here, and it turned out to be an interesting scenario. Normally, lower resolution replacements get rejected as they turn out to be worse in quality, but in this case a technical oversight produced an unfair filesize, plus the replacement shows no degradation over the original

Reply
Lyren

teriri41 said:

Request: replace post #154752 with asset #606934

- hand fix
- dress fix
- still approveable for now

Replaced. Almost all active approvers have already pressed skip on the image, so it's recommended to appeal the image in case it gets deleted.

Never mind, reverted, I just realized it's not even your self-upload. Only self-uploads are allowed to be replaced. Upload it as separate post instead.

Reply
eyeviewer

I got two third-party edits for an image that is apparently getting taken out because of an extra finger. post #154806

https://images-ng.pixai.art/gi/orig/0cef21e1-ec46-4b56-b9d1-6d0f084451af

https://images-ng.pixai.art/gi/orig/d05cfce0-791d-43e9-8c94-9c4897a92f0d

There are options here. We can replace the post with the most similar edit which has fixed hands and keeps the style similar or the second one which is uncensored and condom removed. Either of them would be third-party edits from my own; and if they happen to get through replacement I could tag the image as third-party edit and add my artist tag as colaboration. I'm not sure I understand the rules since people have always had the freedom to uncensor and make third-party edits from original material without permission and post them in other boorus and I don't think it's any different here. The original image will still be the primary source, of course.

Edit: Okay, I see Lyren said only self-uploads are replaceable, but I can't quite get it. I don't want to complain. It's just weird to me that a creator wouldn't be able to enhance an image to get it approved even when there's recognition for the original material in the artist tag, source and upload. One could even say it becomes a half-self-upload after the replacement...

Updated by eyeviewer

Reply
Iroshi

Caprea said:

hey,
i've read the latest disapproval reason of my post #154866 and yea, the style is intentional but i can see why it's not approved.
made some changes and requesting a replacement with this https://files.catbox.moe/x4o62l.jpg if possible.
or is it too different now and should be its own post?

@Caprea The composition is noticeably changed, so it should be a new post by itself. Posts replacements are usually for inpainting or "local regenerations" of the problematic areas. I also wrote the feeback on the post you linked
On a sidenote, I hope to see you post more in the future, you are so talented

Reply
Caprea

Iroshi said:

@Caprea The composition is noticeably changed, so it should be a new post by itself. Posts replacements are usually for inpainting or "local regenerations" of the problematic areas. I also wrote the feeback on the post you linked
On a sidenote, I hope to see you post more in the future, you are so talented

first of all, thanks for the feedback on the upload :3
tried to only fix the hands but that style is a bitch to work with so, lol
i think i'll let this one get deleted and make a post for the new one.
and thanks for the compliment. was just about to upload something new i've been working on. so, more posts will come.. slowly :3

Reply
1 2 3 4